Good Morning!

It’s Thursday, November 28th – Thanksgiving Across the Pond! While Thanksgiving remains a cherished tradition in America, it hasn’t quite taken hold here in the UK. But for those celebrating, we wish you a day filled with gratitude and joy!

Today’s editorial dives into an important topic for our borough, sparked by a press statement from the council last night. We’re talking about the devolution of Hertfordshire and the potential reorganisation of local councils, including our very own Broxbourne.

Let’s unpack what this could mean for us.

Editorial

Press Statement From The Council on Devolution in Hertfordshire and Local Government Reorganisation

Last night, Broxbourne Council issued a statement addressing the growing discussions around devolution and local government reorganisation, sparked by the Chancellor’s recent remarks and the anticipation of the Government’s Devolution White Paper.

The council spokesperson emphasised that the Council is awaiting the White Paper, expected by the end of the year, to understand the Government’s vision for devolution in England and any proposals for local government reform. The document will outline options for areas like Hertfordshire, and the Council is preparing to evaluate what changes, if any, would best serve the residents and businesses of Broxbourne.

In the statement, the Council strongly opposed the potential abolition of district and borough councils, citing concerns about moving local decision-making and service delivery further from the communities they serve. Leader of the Council, Councillor Mark Mills-Bishop, expressed openness to discussions on devolution but stressed the importance of retaining power and accountability at the local level. “We are open to discussions if the government wants to talk about devolution and will study the content of the White Paper,” he stated, “but we do not want local decisions and power moving away from the people and Broxbourne.”

For Some Context

Since 2014, England has pursued devolution through agreements granting local areas greater control over policies such as transport, housing, and economic development. These agreements often establish combined authorities led by directly elected mayors, known as metro mayors. The Levelling Up White Paper, published in February 2022, outlined the government's commitment to expanding devolution across England, proposing a new devolution framework to provide a clear path for areas seeking greater autonomy.

Devolution in England

In September 2024, the UK government agreed to form new mayoral combined authorities for regions including Hull and East Yorkshire, and Greater Lincolnshire, as well as non-mayoral combined authorities for areas like Lancashire and Devon and Torbay. These developments reflect ongoing efforts to extend devolution and reorganise local government structures to better serve communities across England.

Local Government Reorganisation

In November 2024, the UK government announced plans to abolish dozens of councils in counties such as Essex, Kent, Surrey, Hertfordshire, Norfolk, and Suffolk. This significant overhaul aims to replace the existing two-tier system of county and district councils with larger unitary authorities, each serving populations of at least 500,000. The reorganisation is intended to streamline governance, enhance efficiency, and save taxpayers nearly £3 billion over five years. However, some officials express concerns that larger unitary councils could diminish local democratic accountability and disconnect councillors from their communities.

Combined Authorities and Combined County Authorities

Combined authorities (CAs) and combined county authorities (CCAs) are collaborative structures where multiple local authorities work together to manage transport, economic development, and regeneration. CAs, introduced by the Local Democracy, Economic Development and Construction Act 2009, allow groups of local authorities to pool responsibilities and receive devolved functions from central government. CCAs, established under the Levelling-up and Regeneration Act 2023, involve upper-tier authorities like county councils and unitary authorities. Both structures aim to deliver policies more effectively over wider areas.

What Does This Mean for Broxbourne?

The White Paper’s release is expected to present a range of options for Hertfordshire, and with it, the potential for significant changes to Broxbourne’s governance structure. In this editorial, we analyse the possible outcomes that will be outlined in the White Paper, speculating on what each option could mean for the borough’s businesses and residents.

Here is our comprehensive assessment of the potential options and their implications for Broxbourne. We outline the positive, negative, and neutral aspects of each scenario to provide a balanced perspective. Our goal is to inform and spark meaningful conversations among businesses and residents about the future of our borough.

1. Enhanced Devolved Powers Without Structural Change

Outcome:

Broxbourne Council retains its current structure as a borough council but gains new powers in areas like transport, housing, and economic development through a combined authority or county-wide devolution agreement.

Impact on Residents:

• Positive: Residents may benefit from more localised decision-making on critical issues, improving service delivery and fostering economic growth.

• Negative: If poorly coordinated, new responsibilities could strain existing council resources, leading to inefficiencies.

• Neutral: Collaboration with Hertfordshire County Council and other districts could streamline services without significant disruption.

2. Creation of a Hertfordshire-Wide Combined Authority

Outcome:

Broxbourne becomes part of a Hertfordshire Combined Authority, potentially led by a directly elected mayor. The council would share decision-making responsibilities with other districts and boroughs in the county.

Impact on Residents:

• Positive: A unified vision for economic development could attract investment, create jobs, and improve infrastructure.

• Negative: Decision-making may become more centralized, diluting Broxbourne’s unique needs and priorities. Residents may feel their voices are less heard in a broader governance framework.

• Neutral: The role of Broxbourne Council may shift to a more advisory capacity, with day-to-day services remaining unaffected.

3. Abolition of District and Borough Councils in Favor of a Unitary Authority

Outcome:

Broxbourne Council is dissolved, and Hertfordshire transitions to a unitary authority system, consolidating all district and borough councils into one or two larger governing bodies.

Impact on Residents:

• Positive: Consolidation may lead to cost savings and more streamlined service delivery. Larger budgets could support county-wide infrastructure projects and social programs.

• Negative: Residents may feel disconnected from local decision-making as governance moves further away from the community level. Smaller, local issues might not receive adequate attention.

• Neutral: Service levels could depend on how well the new authority adapts to managing a larger, more diverse region.

4. A Hybrid Model with Retained Local Councils but Limited Powers

Outcome:

Broxbourne Council remains, but its powers are reduced as key functions are transferred to Hertfordshire County Council or a combined authority.

Impact on Residents:

• Positive: Retaining a local council ensures continued representation for Broxbourne residents.

• Negative: The reduced scope of local governance may lead to delays in addressing community-specific issues.

• Neutral: Residents may experience minimal changes in day-to-day services, depending on how effectively responsibilities are divided.

5. Resistance to Devolution Leads to Status Quo

Outcome:

Broxbourne Council and other Hertfordshire districts maintain their current structures without significant changes to powers or responsibilities.

Impact on Residents:

• Positive: Familiar governance structures ensure continuity and retain strong local representation.

• Negative: Missed opportunities for funding and development initiatives tied to devolution.

• Neutral: Residents continue to rely on the current system, which may lack the resources or coordination for major county-wide improvements.

Broxbourne Residents: What’s at Stake?

Just to be clear, the options above are all hypothetical and the White Paper will provide details of the options available to Broxbourne. Regardless of the outcome, the impact on Broxbourne residents will hinge on how effectively the new or existing governance structures address community needs. Key areas to watch include:

1. Local Representation: Will residents feel adequately represented in decision-making processes?

2. Service Delivery: How will changes affect the efficiency and quality of services like waste collection, housing, and public transport?

3. Economic Opportunities: Will devolution bring tangible benefits such as job creation and infrastructure investment to Broxbourne?

Final Thoughts:

The government’s devolution plans bring both potential opportunities and challenges for Broxbourne. While greater powers could help the borough tackle local issues more effectively, significant structural changes risk distancing governance from the residents it serves. Success will depend on striking the right balance between broader strategic goals and the unique needs of our community.

We’re committed to keeping you informed every step of the way, delivering updates straight to your inbox. Your voice will be essential in shaping how devolution impacts our borough, so stay engaged and let’s navigate this together.

Thats all!

We'll see you again tomorrow bright and early!

Got Question or Suggestions to make our Newsletter better? Click here

Got a Story? Email [email protected].

If you want to advertise here please email us.

... and if someone forwarded this email to you, thank them 😉, and subscribe here!

Have a wonderful rest of your day.

Cheers

Broxtown Newsletter Team